Writing, Writing, Writing
Both Jack in Sharon Creech’s Love That Dog, and Page in Mara Casey and Stephen I. Hemenway’s Structure and Freedom: Achieving a Balanced Writing Curriculum were involved in the 5 stages of the writing process. Although their stories are different, and their respective teachers’ methods of going through the 5 stages were carried out in different ways, both Jack and Page began by pre-writing, followed by drafting, revising, editing, and finally publishing their work.
Pre-Writing
The pre-writing stage often occurs before students ever touch a pencil to paper. As discussed in class, teachers should bring in good examples of the writing types and styles that will then be attempted by students. In doing so, the teacher is not only exposing students to good quality literature, but also focussing the lesson and activity to come. Jack’s teacher, Miss Stretchberry, did an excellent job of bringing in and modelling a wide variety of great examples of poetry in Jack’s class. Miss Stretchberry then facilitated the pre-writing stage by having Jack write in a journal. This safe space that only the student and teacher had access to allowed Jack to honestly express his thoughts and questions about the poetry recited in class, and to eventually start drafting his own poems.
Drafting and Revising
During the writing of the first draft, students should focus on what is being said rather than the way in which they’re saying it. Pre-writing ties into the first draft since drafting is a form of organised free-writing. Pre-writing brings together the main ideas to be written, while the draft is a rough first attempt at putting those ideas on paper in some order. Revising is then done by looking at the draft and rearranging, removing, and adding ideas. In Page’s grade 3 class, writing groups hosted the revising stage. Page obtained feedback and advice from her peers on her drafts. She then rewrote many subsequent drafts to accommodate changes based on her classmates’ suggestions, and her own feelings towards her piece. In contrast, Jack’s revising came not from a group setting, but rather from feedback and encouragement from Miss Stretchberry in his journal. Peer, self, and teacher discussion of students’ writings are all integral parts of the revision process as discussed in class, and all forms should be used both on their own and in combination.
Editing
Editing is the fourth stage of the writing process, and is based on proofreading to identify and make corrections to sentence structure, spelling mistakes, grammar, and other mechanical errors. As mentioned by Tompkins, Bright, Pollard, and Winsor in Language Arts Content and Teaching Strategies, for newer writers, editing is often skipped or only lightly touched on to promote content (Language Arts, p.151), and to not have students disheartened by a draft full of red pen marks. Although Miss Stretchberry does not put a strong focus on editing in her poetry unit, Jack begins to self-edit his poems on his own by deciding on spacing between lines (Love That Dog, p.38) and by discovering the spell-check when learning how to type on the computer (Love That Dog, p.67). Similarly, by the time Page has reached grade 6, she knows there are “predictable stages” to the writing process including editing. Unfortunately the only revision taking place in her class was the editing stage; “You don’t have time to revise. ... you read it over and correct run-on sentences or bad English” (Structure and Freedom, p.71).
Publishing
After all the hard work of pre-writing, drafting, revising, and editing, a final polished copy is ready for the publishing stage. For many students, this is the most exciting part of the writing process as they get to share their finished pieces. Publishing has many forms and can depend on the type of writing, or the theme of the unit. Books, letters, posters, drawings, recordings, and reports are only some of the ways in which students can choose to have their work on display for others to read, listen, or observe. For Page, her 3rd grade class got to publish a class book at the end of the year with individual stories from all of the students. Page was excited and enthusiastic about this prospect, and it encouraged her to work hard on making her story as good as it could be. Because this project was student-centered in that students had the choice to write about whatever they chose, Page strived to perform to the best of her abilities. Contrarily, in both of her grade 8 and 10 interviews, Page stated that the publishing stage was restricted to structured essays and reports written only for teachers’ eyes. For this reason, Page had no interest in her writing and didn’t try to push her abilities as a writer. She chose only to publish whatever she could get away with to get a decent grade. Thankfully in Jack’s class, Miss Stretchberry helped the students publish their work by typing up their poems on colourful paper to display for the class. Jack was at first reluctant to publish his work for the class, and Miss Stretchberry acknowledged his decision yet encouraged him to seek confidence in his abilities. Eventually Jack even went as far as learning to type to publish his own poems for the class.
Methods to the Madness
Both Jack and Page went through the 5 stages of the writing process, yet some of the teaching methods used to move through the steps proved more effective than others. Along with other aspects, a well-organized and engaging writing classroom should incorporate student-centered lesson plans, a variety of types of literature, and effective group discussions.
As referenced earlier, Page’s grade 3 teacher did a great job of giving students the choice of their topic, therefore engaging students in the writing process. This model of a student-centered lesson plan was efficient because even though students had the freedom to choose, they also had well structured guidelines incorporating learning outcomes. Alternatively, Page’s middle and high school writing assignments were teacher-focused with little to no freedom of choice of topic or writing style. Page cemented this theory by explaining that she wished “teachers understood that kids need freedom of expression” (Structure and Freedom, p.73). The lack of choice in her grade 8 class resulted in Page’s lack of enthusiasm, and as a result, mediocre work.
Another aspect of an engaging classroom is the use of a wide range of different types of literature for students to view/read and for students to write/represent. As discussed in class, bringing in good examples of all types of literature will be valuable to students’ emergent literacy. In Miss Stretchberry’s poetry unit for example, she made sure to expose her students to a wide variety of poems by distinguished authors, as well as exposing students eachother’s poems. Having access to such a rich reservoir of examples is sure to further students’ schematas, thus their comprehension of the literature. This will in turn help students to generate better writing. I plan to incorporate a variety of types and sources of literature in my own writing classroom as well. Having a wide resource base will be a key factor to gaining access to appropriate and meaningful literature. To broaden my repertoire of literature, I intend to be well connected to my school’s librarian, the computer lab instructor, the IRP’s suggested literature, and other colleagues’ recommendations, among other resources.
When peer conferencing was first mentioned in class, I was sceptical of its benefits. This is because my own experience with peer conferencing was much like Page’s grade 8 exchanges of papers with classmates. They were meant to revise and proofread for their classmates, but instead Page admits that it’s not very useful by stating: “I don’t think kids really take it seriously” (Structure and Freedom, p.72). When reading back to her grade 3 experience in group work however, it is clear that the conferencing was effective. Page notes: “I like being in my writing group, because you get more attention on your story” (Structure and Freedom, p.69). Now that I understand that group work is more than just proofreading of each other’s work, I see the multiple benefits of this method. I intend to integrate effective peer conferencing in my own writing classroom by ensuring a comfortable setting in which students can feel like respected social citizens. To develop this confidence with each other within my class, I will encourage class discussions and debates, and play social games to lessen inhibitions some students might have in sharing their thoughts and opinions.
Just because a teacher uses a writing workshop doesn’t mean it will be an effective tool in improving students’ writing. The methods in which I choose as a teacher to approach the workshop are just as important as the process itself. Like Nancy Atwell suggests, I will strive to construct “purposeful, caring, and supportive classrooms”. I plan to do this not just with the resources I’m given, but also with a thoughtful and focused approach.
Both Jack in Sharon Creech’s Love That Dog, and Page in Mara Casey and Stephen I. Hemenway’s Structure and Freedom: Achieving a Balanced Writing Curriculum were involved in the 5 stages of the writing process. Although their stories are different, and their respective teachers’ methods of going through the 5 stages were carried out in different ways, both Jack and Page began by pre-writing, followed by drafting, revising, editing, and finally publishing their work.
Pre-Writing
The pre-writing stage often occurs before students ever touch a pencil to paper. As discussed in class, teachers should bring in good examples of the writing types and styles that will then be attempted by students. In doing so, the teacher is not only exposing students to good quality literature, but also focussing the lesson and activity to come. Jack’s teacher, Miss Stretchberry, did an excellent job of bringing in and modelling a wide variety of great examples of poetry in Jack’s class. Miss Stretchberry then facilitated the pre-writing stage by having Jack write in a journal. This safe space that only the student and teacher had access to allowed Jack to honestly express his thoughts and questions about the poetry recited in class, and to eventually start drafting his own poems.
Drafting and Revising
During the writing of the first draft, students should focus on what is being said rather than the way in which they’re saying it. Pre-writing ties into the first draft since drafting is a form of organised free-writing. Pre-writing brings together the main ideas to be written, while the draft is a rough first attempt at putting those ideas on paper in some order. Revising is then done by looking at the draft and rearranging, removing, and adding ideas. In Page’s grade 3 class, writing groups hosted the revising stage. Page obtained feedback and advice from her peers on her drafts. She then rewrote many subsequent drafts to accommodate changes based on her classmates’ suggestions, and her own feelings towards her piece. In contrast, Jack’s revising came not from a group setting, but rather from feedback and encouragement from Miss Stretchberry in his journal. Peer, self, and teacher discussion of students’ writings are all integral parts of the revision process as discussed in class, and all forms should be used both on their own and in combination.
Editing
Editing is the fourth stage of the writing process, and is based on proofreading to identify and make corrections to sentence structure, spelling mistakes, grammar, and other mechanical errors. As mentioned by Tompkins, Bright, Pollard, and Winsor in Language Arts Content and Teaching Strategies, for newer writers, editing is often skipped or only lightly touched on to promote content (Language Arts, p.151), and to not have students disheartened by a draft full of red pen marks. Although Miss Stretchberry does not put a strong focus on editing in her poetry unit, Jack begins to self-edit his poems on his own by deciding on spacing between lines (Love That Dog, p.38) and by discovering the spell-check when learning how to type on the computer (Love That Dog, p.67). Similarly, by the time Page has reached grade 6, she knows there are “predictable stages” to the writing process including editing. Unfortunately the only revision taking place in her class was the editing stage; “You don’t have time to revise. ... you read it over and correct run-on sentences or bad English” (Structure and Freedom, p.71).
Publishing
After all the hard work of pre-writing, drafting, revising, and editing, a final polished copy is ready for the publishing stage. For many students, this is the most exciting part of the writing process as they get to share their finished pieces. Publishing has many forms and can depend on the type of writing, or the theme of the unit. Books, letters, posters, drawings, recordings, and reports are only some of the ways in which students can choose to have their work on display for others to read, listen, or observe. For Page, her 3rd grade class got to publish a class book at the end of the year with individual stories from all of the students. Page was excited and enthusiastic about this prospect, and it encouraged her to work hard on making her story as good as it could be. Because this project was student-centered in that students had the choice to write about whatever they chose, Page strived to perform to the best of her abilities. Contrarily, in both of her grade 8 and 10 interviews, Page stated that the publishing stage was restricted to structured essays and reports written only for teachers’ eyes. For this reason, Page had no interest in her writing and didn’t try to push her abilities as a writer. She chose only to publish whatever she could get away with to get a decent grade. Thankfully in Jack’s class, Miss Stretchberry helped the students publish their work by typing up their poems on colourful paper to display for the class. Jack was at first reluctant to publish his work for the class, and Miss Stretchberry acknowledged his decision yet encouraged him to seek confidence in his abilities. Eventually Jack even went as far as learning to type to publish his own poems for the class.
Methods to the Madness
Both Jack and Page went through the 5 stages of the writing process, yet some of the teaching methods used to move through the steps proved more effective than others. Along with other aspects, a well-organized and engaging writing classroom should incorporate student-centered lesson plans, a variety of types of literature, and effective group discussions.
As referenced earlier, Page’s grade 3 teacher did a great job of giving students the choice of their topic, therefore engaging students in the writing process. This model of a student-centered lesson plan was efficient because even though students had the freedom to choose, they also had well structured guidelines incorporating learning outcomes. Alternatively, Page’s middle and high school writing assignments were teacher-focused with little to no freedom of choice of topic or writing style. Page cemented this theory by explaining that she wished “teachers understood that kids need freedom of expression” (Structure and Freedom, p.73). The lack of choice in her grade 8 class resulted in Page’s lack of enthusiasm, and as a result, mediocre work.
Another aspect of an engaging classroom is the use of a wide range of different types of literature for students to view/read and for students to write/represent. As discussed in class, bringing in good examples of all types of literature will be valuable to students’ emergent literacy. In Miss Stretchberry’s poetry unit for example, she made sure to expose her students to a wide variety of poems by distinguished authors, as well as exposing students eachother’s poems. Having access to such a rich reservoir of examples is sure to further students’ schematas, thus their comprehension of the literature. This will in turn help students to generate better writing. I plan to incorporate a variety of types and sources of literature in my own writing classroom as well. Having a wide resource base will be a key factor to gaining access to appropriate and meaningful literature. To broaden my repertoire of literature, I intend to be well connected to my school’s librarian, the computer lab instructor, the IRP’s suggested literature, and other colleagues’ recommendations, among other resources.
When peer conferencing was first mentioned in class, I was sceptical of its benefits. This is because my own experience with peer conferencing was much like Page’s grade 8 exchanges of papers with classmates. They were meant to revise and proofread for their classmates, but instead Page admits that it’s not very useful by stating: “I don’t think kids really take it seriously” (Structure and Freedom, p.72). When reading back to her grade 3 experience in group work however, it is clear that the conferencing was effective. Page notes: “I like being in my writing group, because you get more attention on your story” (Structure and Freedom, p.69). Now that I understand that group work is more than just proofreading of each other’s work, I see the multiple benefits of this method. I intend to integrate effective peer conferencing in my own writing classroom by ensuring a comfortable setting in which students can feel like respected social citizens. To develop this confidence with each other within my class, I will encourage class discussions and debates, and play social games to lessen inhibitions some students might have in sharing their thoughts and opinions.
Just because a teacher uses a writing workshop doesn’t mean it will be an effective tool in improving students’ writing. The methods in which I choose as a teacher to approach the workshop are just as important as the process itself. Like Nancy Atwell suggests, I will strive to construct “purposeful, caring, and supportive classrooms”. I plan to do this not just with the resources I’m given, but also with a thoughtful and focused approach.
.